Some thoughts for Thursday on Visual Rhetoric

PicassoGuernicaCapa,_Death_of_a_Loyalist_Soldier

Few need an introduction to Picasso, and fewer still to this powerful statement created as a protest against a conflict of his time, The Spanish Civil War. Guernica was painted in 1937. But I would like to consider for a moment – Why did he choose black and white for this image?  Why not color? If one considers his palette of this period, it most certainly would be color.  Not black and white. Indeed, this paintings’ lack of color is an anomaly in Picasso’s body of work.  I would suggest maybe because of images like Robert Capa’s Death of a Spanish Loyalist Soldier.  This photograph was taken in 1936. This image, and images like this were being printed and reproduced in many of the newspapers of the day.

By 1937, Picasso was already aware of the power, the representational “truth” that the news photograph conveyed.  He understood and invoked the visual rhetoric of the news photograph.  And it was conveyed in black and white. The materiality of the photograph, its’ formal concerns, imbue it with it’s content.  With it’s conceptual punch.

While I was having dinner a couple years ago with colleagues, Professor Iris Ford remarked that she had considered replacing the family pictures in her den, which were in color, with black and white reproductions of them. She felt these color images documenting her family didn’t have the same significance as the black and white ones she remembered in her mother’s den. They didn’t feel real – authentic.

Colby Caldwell

Similar Articles

Asheville Grit on Photo+C... (from article by Ali McGhee, published in Asheville Grit, with new photos) The inaugural photo+craft event, which takes place from March 31-April 3rd in downtown Asheville and
Writers on Photography posted by Colby Caldwell “In my photographic work I was always especially entranced, said Austerlitz, by the moment when the shadows of reality so to speak, emerge
ArtReport: Fred Ritchin S... (by Alison Sher, reprinted from ARTREPORT) Fred Ritchin has built his career on using documentary photography to promote democracy. At Asheville’s first ever photo+craft festival, he presented
New ways of depicting and... In Asheville, at the Intersection of Photography & Craft    (An interview with Fred Ritchin in BURNAWAY – the Voice of Art in the South, by Diana
“Ghosts in the Mach... “Technically the pictures are compiled in Photoshop so that the figures that are falling and the backgrounds are from different places. I’d also thought about combining technology
Of Refugees and the Photo... Hot off the press! photo+craft keynote speaker Fred Ritchin’s essay examines photography of the refugee crisis (in recent “Odyssey” issue of Aperture magazine).  Read it here and come to his
The Haptics of Optics: We... (posted by Anna Helgeson) Get yourself a nice cup of tea and curl up with this brilliant chapter from T’ai Smith’s book Bauhaus Weaving Theory: From Feminine
Framing Lazarus                 notes on work for gun shy and how to survive your own death by Colby Caldwell 1. “We are
Ann Hamilton and Sally Ma... (By Ann Batchelder) Photographs and textiles provide clues to a personal as well as cultural presence. Both reference time and place; both also absorb light and memory
Photography: A New Way to...     “…..the word ‘photography’ today names not another visual form of representation, but an immersive economy that offers an entirely new way to inhabit materiality and